ARIZARD-L Archives

Archiver > ARIZARD > 2011-02 > 1297294505


From: Don Ott <>
Subject: Re: [ARIZARD] Elbert - Don & June
Date: Wed, 09 Feb 2011 17:35:05 -0600
References: <201102091626.p19GQjw2016227@mail941c35.nsolutionszone.com><858457.81449.qm@web31506.mail.mud.yahoo.com>
In-Reply-To: <858457.81449.qm@web31506.mail.mud.yahoo.com>


Marsha,
Gosh thank you so much, I went through
your entire submission and we agree on 99.9% of
what you have. There is one major disagreement.
The person you list as 1st generation is
different than I have as the father of Elbert
Benbrook "Old" born 1807 Warren, TN and Henry
Benbrook b. 17 Dec 1812, Warren TN. I have their
father as Charles Benbrookb 1780 ,Montgomery NC,
the son of Ezekiel Gould Benbrook b. Dec 1748
Donles, Johnson, Ncand Mary McGuiar b 1759,
Goochland, VA. In other words I have an extra
generation in there, however I do not know the
name of the wife of Charles Benbrook.
Maybe others can comment on this, am I all wet.
Don



At 04:02 PM 2/9/2011, you wrote:
>The way I remember things - the dance about
>Elbert starts with "which one is which"
>and wen on and on. How many are there helps by
>labeling them "Old" and "Young" because there
>are many opinions on other given names: like "Charles Elbert"
>See if this helps or hurts . . . Marsha
>ARIzard archives
>http://archiver.rootsweb.ancestry.com/th/read/arizard/2000-07/0964877423
>
>
>1 Ezekiel Gould Benbrook
>
>..... 2 Elbert Benbrook b: 1807
>
>......... +Mary Chapman d: Bet. 1832 - 1837 m: April 22,
> 1828 in , Summer,
>
>Kentucky
>
>............. 3 Mary Benbrook b: November 1830 in , Montgomery, Missouri
>
>d: May 07, 1904
>
>................. +Granderson Graves Guthrie b: Abt. 1824 in Tennessee d:
>
>Aft. 1860
>
>............. *2nd Husband of Mary Benbrook:
>
>................. +Unknown Bowling b: Abt. 1830
>
>............. *3rd Husband of Mary Benbrook:
>
>................. +Unknown Ferguson
>
>............. 3 William B. Benbrook b: 1832
>
>..... *2nd Wife of Elbert Benbrook:
>
>......... +Sarah Langston b: 1812 in Illinois d: Abt. 1856 m: Bef. 1837
>
>............. 3 Sarah Benbrook b: 1837 d: 1879
>
>................. +William Wood b: 1825 d: 1877
>
>.................... 4 Emma Wood b: 1862
>
>........................ +James A. Kerr b: 1857 m: 1882
>
>.................... 4 Mary Wood b: November 28, 1863 in , Izard, Arkansas
>
>d: 1901
>
>........................ +Thomas J. Matthews b: September 06,
> 1855 d: 1909
>
>m: October 30, 1879
>
>.................... 4 Harriett Wood b: 1866
>
>........................ +Cyrus James Creswell b: Aft. 1854
>
>.................... 4 William Wood b: 1868
>
>.................... 4 Frances Wood b: 1870
>
>........................ +Unknown Benbrook
>
>.................... 4 Charles E. Wood b: Bet. 1872 - 1873
>
>.................... 4 Annie Wood b: Bet. 1874 - 1875 d: 1908
>
>........................ +Charlie Monroe Grimmett b: February 25,
> 1870 d:
>
>February
> 02, 1949 m: April 25,
> 1891
>
>............. 3 Elizabeth Benbrook b: February 1840 in , Izard, Arkansas
>
>d: 1910 in , Sharp, Arkansas
>
>................. +Thomas B. Culp b: 1833 in Arkansas d: March 08, 1880
>
>in Melbourne, Izard, Arkansas
>
>.................... 4 W. Henry Culp b: Aft. 1854 d: in Mammoth Springs
>
> Arkansas
>
>........................ +Anna Owens b: Aft. 1846
>
>.................... 4 Josephine Culp b: Aft. 1854
>
>........................ +Archie Nicks b: Abt. 1867
>
>.................... 4 Mattie Culp b: Aft. 1854
>
>........................ +Unknown Wiseman b: Aft. 1846
>
>.................... 4 Charles W. Culp b: May 14, 1858 in Arkansas d:
>
>1926 in Mammoth Spring, Sharp, Arkansas
>
>........................ +Joannah C. Sharp b: December 04,
> 1861 in , Sharp,
>
>Arkansas d: 1947 m: December 22, 1880
>
>.................... 4 Ambrose F. Culp b: 1860
>
>............. *2nd Husband of Elizabeth Benbrook:
>
>................. +J. M. Cook b: Abt. 1840 m: November 18,
> 1888 in ,
>
>Fulton, Arkansas
>
>............. 3 Armitta F. Benbrook b: Bet. 1841 - 1842
>
>............. 3 Charles Elbert Benbrook b: 1844 d: 1913
>
>..... 2 Henry Benbrook b: Bet. 1811 - 1812 d: 1872
>
>......... +Catherine Langston d: Bef. 1845
>
>............. 3 Ezekial Benbrook b: Abt. 1835
>
>............. 3 Elbert Benbrook b: June 23, 1838 in , Izard, Arkansas d:
>
>July
> 04, 1919
>
>................. +Margaret M. Berry b: 1843 in Georgia d: January 03,
>
> 1871 m: 1861
>
>.................... 4 Susan A. Benbrook b: 1862
>
>........................ +W. J. Hudson
>
>.................... 4 Robert Henry Benbrook b: 1864 d: 1949
>
>........................ +Mary Frances Kidwell b: 1868 d: 1951 m: 1884
>
>.................... 4 Martha Catherine Benbrook b: March 1869 d: 1925
>
>........................ +Walter Claudius Rodman b: January 1859 in
>
>Kentucky d: 1931 m: 1887
>
>............. *2nd Wife of Elbert Benbrook:
>
>................. +Sarah Ann Mathes b: 1837 d: July 16, 1878 m: October 10,
>
> 1871 in
>LaCrosse, Izard, Arkansas
>
>.................... 4 Margie Alice Benbrook b: October 27,
> 1872 d: July
>
> 31, 1958
>
>.................... 4 Dora Elbertie Benbrook b: December 30,
> 1874
>
>........................ +John Crittenden Jones b: December 19,
> 1874 in ,
>
>Fulton, Arkansas m: December 20, 1905
>
>.................... 4 Allen Harvey Benbrook b: February 25,
> 1877
>
>........................ +Lela Alburties McSpadden b: November 24,
> 1878 in
>
>Mount Pleasant, Izard, Arkansas d: April 22, 1967 in Teague, Freestone,
>
>Texas m: November 26, 1902
>
>............. *3rd Wife of Elbert Benbrook:
>
>................. +Elizabeth Slyre b: February 16, 1834 d: March 01, 1902
>
>m: 1878
>
>............. *4th Wife of Elbert Benbrook:
>
>................. +Elizabeth Greenhaw b: November 13, 1851 d: March 07,
>
> 1907 m: Abt.
>1906
>
>............. *5th Wife of Elbert Benbrook:
>
>................. +Sarah E. Franks b: March 1857 in Tennessee m: May 29,
>
> 1907
>
>............. *6th Wife of Elbert Benbrook:
>
>................. +Judith Lysle Mathes b: August 18, 1845 in New Market,
>
>Claiborne, Tennessee d: Aft. 1925 m: September 19, 1917
>
>..... *2nd Wife of Henry Benbrook:
>
>......... +Elizabeth Traylor b: Bet. 1825 - 1828 in Indiana d: 1868 m:
>
>Abt. 1845
>
>............. 3 Maria Jane Benbrook b: November 03, 1846 in Arkansas d:
>
>December 19, 1906 in , Izard, Arkansas
>
>................. +David Hume Smith b: September 14, 1847 in Missouri d:
>
>January 29, 1923 in , Izard, Arkansas m: 1870
>
>.................... 4 Benjamin B. Smith b: Abt. 1872
>
>.................... 4 Elizabeth C. Smith b: Abt. 1874
>
>.................... 4 Mary F. Smith b: Abt. 1877
>
>.................... 4 Rena A. Smith b: Abt. 1879
>
>............. 3 Uen Benbrook b: Abt. 1848 in , Izard, Arkansas d: April
>
> 17, 1925
>
>................. +[1] Asenath Long b: September 25, 1851 in , Izard,
>
> Arkansas d: February 19, 1916 m: Aft. 1870
>
>.................... 4 Elizabeth Benbrook b: May 22, 1873
>
>........................ +James L. Blankenship b: September 09,
> 1877 in ,
>
>Izard, Arkansas
>
>.................... 4 Angelene A. Benbrook b: 1875
>
>.................... 4 Albert Benbrook b: 1877
>
>.................... 4 Robert Benbrook b: Aft. 1870
>
>.................... 4 Acie Benbrook b: Aft. 1870
>
>.................... 4 Elbert Benbrook b: Aft. 1870
>
>............. 3 Angeline Armitta Benbrook b: Abt. 1849
>
>................. +Green Porter Staggs m: Abt. 1870 in , Izard, Arkansas
>
>............. 3 Serenia V. Benbrook b: 1854
>
>................. +A. J. Franks
>
>............. 3 Charlotte T. Benbrook b: Bet. 1858 - 1860
>
>................. +Levi L. Bailey b: Abt. 1856 in Mississippi m: Bef.
>
>1878
>
>.................... 4 William H. Bailey b: Abt. 1878
>
>............. 3 Perry Benbrook b: August 08, 1860
>
>................. +Margaret E. Wyatt
>
>............. 3 Nancy Benbrook b: 1862 d: Bef. 1900
>
>............. 3 Henry Benbrook b: October 01, 1865 in Arkansas d: Aft.
>
>1920
>
>................. +Prisilla Long b: September 1861 d: Aft. 1920 m: Abt.
>
>1887
>
>.................... 4 Nola Augustus Benbrook b: March 08, 1888 in
>
>Arkansas d: September 28, 1927 in Arkansas
>
>........................ +William Murdock Hays b: June 15, 1884 in Newburg,
>
>Izard, Arkansas d: September 01, 1935 in Arkansas m: March 23, 1910 in ,
>
>Izard, Arkansas
>
>.................... 4 Luther Benbrook b: November 1889
>
>.................... 4 Eoxnie Benbrook b: February 1890
>
>.................... 4 William Benbrook b: March 1898
>
>............. 3 Washington Benbrook b: 1852 d: 1870
>
>................. +[1] Asenath Long b: September 25, 1851 in , Izard,
>
> Arkansas d: February 19, 1916 m: Bef. 1870
>
>
>
>
>
>--- On Wed, 2/9/11, Don Ott <> wrote:
>
>From: Don Ott <>
>Subject: Re: [ARIZARD] Morning.
>To:
>Date: Wednesday, February 9, 2011, 10:26 AM
>
>June and others.
>Â Â Â Â Â Â In the 1850 Census Arkansas, Izard,
>Union, Elbert Benbrook is listed with his second
>wife Sarah "Sallie" Langston. His second child,
>with his first wife, William B. Benbrook 17, is
>living with them, shown as a child. Then the
>children of Sarah: Sarah, Elizabeth, Armintta and
>Charles are listed also as children. Now the
>puzzle. The last person is listed as Mary C.
>Clifton 19. I wonder if that in fact is not his
>first child with his first wife Mary A. "Polly"
>Chapman. The age and name is right but I had her
>married to Guthrie and Bowling and Ferguson and
>did not have her married to Clifton. (Note
>Ancestry translates that as Lefton, but as I look
>at the original I believe it is Clifton.)
>Â Â Â Â Â Â Any one have comments on this?
>Don
>
>
>At 09:10 AM 2/9/2011, you wrote:
> >Snowing like mad here in Henderson ,Ar. Baxter
> >Co this morning. keeps this up we will get a
> >little more than a dusting. Ha! Suppose to warm
> >up this week end so maybe it won’t last long.
>.
> >
> >Just in case some one is interested .
> >I seen in the new Jan 2011 Izard Co Historian on
> >page 26 it mentions at the top Marriage Licenses
> >issued from the Clipper L.L.(Lemuel Levi) Bailey
> >to Charlotte “Lottie) L. Benbrook. I have them
>
> >in my Benbrook Book. She was d/o Henry Benbrook
> >Sr and 2nd wife Elizabeth Trayler. They are
> >buried Oakley Chapel Cem Benton co. Ar. (on find
> >a grave.com) Henry Benbrook b. 1812 was brother
> >to my gggranpa Elbert Benbrook. b.1807.
> >
> >Does any one know where Elbert is buried? all
> >I have is Union Twp. 1807 ­1865. they are in 1850 census book.
> >Thanks June
> >
> >-------------------------------
> >To unsubscribe from the list, please send an
> >email to with the
> >word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the
> >subject and the body of the message
>
>
>
>-------------------------------
>To unsubscribe from the list, please send an
>email to with the
>word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the
>subject and the body of the message
>
>
>
>
>
>-------------------------------
>To unsubscribe from the list, please send an
>email to with the
>word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the
>subject and the body of the message


This thread: